Friday, January 11, 2013

The government, Indians and Canadian racism



There is a lot of anger in Canada right now, much of it divided along racial lines. A good deal of the blame for this rests on government policy that is outdated and blatantly racist.

Several years ago my mother told me a story that I have never forgotten. She had gone into the local convenience store, to pick up some bread or milk. In the store were two little girls, about seven or eight years old and obviously best friends. They were giggling together and counting their coins, trying to decide what to buy. Eventually they each picked up the same chocolate bar, and went to the cashier.

The first little girl put her candy on the counter. The cashier put in the cost, and the tax, and told her the price. She paid him. The second girl placed her chocolate bar on the counter, and was charged only the cost, without tax. The first child noticed this, and said “Hey, how come I had to pay more than she did?” The cashier answered “Because she’s Indian”.

This didn’t satisfy the girl, who turned to her best friend for an answer: “How come I have to pay more than you do?” Her friend shrugged, and said “Because I’m Indian”.

And that is where the anger, and the division into “us” and “them” begins. One side is bitter because they pay taxes and do not get the “perks” of the other. The other side is angry because they don’t have enough of what they need.

Another story, this one from a news outlet. They were telling, very sympathetically, the plight of an Indian man who had not had working plumbing for 20 years. He was still waiting for the government to fix it. At no point did he appear to consider hiring a plumber to pay for having it fixed himself, nor did the story mention this as an option.

I know that treaties were signed between the English and the Indians hundreds of years ago. I don’t really care. Times change for everyone. This is Canada, and all of us, no matter what race, should have the same rights and the same responsibilities. We should all pay taxes. There should be no special funds available to “Aboriginals” only.

I am not asking for, nor do I wish, cultural assimilation. Canada has always succeeded as a mixing bowl of many cultures. I am speaking strictly of equal treatment under the law for all races.